Henry Hyde’s Wargaming Compendium

Some time ago when browsing the various wargaming forums, I came across a discussion thread on terrain quality. Some guy asked what people played on, and almost all of the commenters described their custom made boards or battle mats. This was fine and sometimes even interesting. What bothered me, though, was the constant denigration of ‘thoses stupid felt rags’. People seemed to outdo themselves in claiming how they would never play with anyone who used green felt as their gaming surface. Now, as I myself use a green felt cloth, I started to wonder if I should feel bad about it: Am I cheap, lazy or aesthetically challenged? Am I just not getting what wargaming is all about?

In his recent book The Wargaming Compendium, Henry Hyde has the intention of explaining what wargaming is all about. And to come straight to the point: It’s about many things, but certainly not about snobbery.

I first came across Henry Hyde when I discovered Battlegames Magazine on the Ganesha Games website. I got hooked on the style of the magazine and gradually purchased all of the pdf issues. When Henry took over Miniature Wargames, I immediately subscribed. Later, I discovered View from the Veranda and enjoyed listening to Henry (and Neil Shuck, of course) rambling about all kinds of subjects wargames-related. After a long break from gaming, this made for a very pleasant welcome back: I had discovered that wargamers can be fun, open-minded individuals with a wide range of interests and a reflective stance towards gaming and the gaming world.

So my expectations where rather high when the long announced book finally appeared. And they were not disappointed. The Wargaming Compedium serves a double purpose: On the one hand, it is a great introduction to the world of wargaming. The chapter on basic concepts not only covers means of representing troops, the battlefield and chance (dice and cards), but also delivers a thoughtful explanation of scale issues – having never deliberately pondered about that, I found the discussion most illuminating. Another chapter leads the reader through some 4000 years of military history and examines the possibilities of gaming different periods, including fantasy and science fiction. Generally, I very much like the attitude of treating science fiction and fantasy as just another period – as Henry once said, wargaming is a broad church and crossovers between the different creeds have certainly enriched and refreshened the hobby.

A tome of treasures
A tome of treasures

The chapters on terrain making and painting are inspiring and full of practical hints and short tutorials. The book even includes three sets of rules: one for duels, another one for small scale skirmishes (gunfights in the Old West) and one for battles in the horse-and-musket era. All this will be of great use for beginners, for whom the book serves as a comprehensive guideline for starting their own wargaming activities. However, the book also addresses the grognard and contains a plethora of information that will fascinate the more experienced gamer. Having a keen interest in the history of wargaming, I found the respective chapter especially rewarding. But there is also a wealth of practical tips that may be new even to the most seasoned hand – and if not, at least here they are assembled in one easily accessible volume. I for one have already stuck a post it to the horse colour plate, which has been consulted many times since. I also very much enjoyed the information on figure sculpting and casting – even if I will never sculpt a figure myself, I still think it is interesting to know how the production side of things works.

This already points to the aspect I enjoy most: namely the approach to the hobby The Wargaming Compendium propagates. Wargaming is described as a low-threshold hobby where hours of fun can be had with a couple of figures and a lot of imagination. What for Henry probably only reflects his enthusiasm for the Old School approach, for me reads almost like a deliberate subversion of the increasing commercialization of gaming. The book promotes a hands-on approach and encourages the reader to get rid of the constraints of integrated gaming systems or the norms set up by glossy magazines and instead to trust in his or her own inspiration. At least for me, this is what wargaming is all about.


11 thoughts on “Henry Hyde’s Wargaming Compendium

  1. Quirkworthy October 19, 2013 / 8:59 am

    Regarding terrain, you should play on whatever you want, can be bothered to make and can afford. It might be nice to play on diorama quality tabletops, but few can afford or have the skills to make them. I think it’s laudable to push the boundaries of quality and try to make the models and terrain as attractive as we can, but at the end of the day this is a hobby and it’s supposed to be fun. If all you need to imagine the battlefield is a green cloth, then go to it.

    Over the years I’ve fought over all manner of different model battlefields, from bare tabletops to top quality studio-made bespoke scenery. The top end stuff is prettier to look at, but does it make the game better? Maybe. By an amount that makes the effort worthwhile? Debatable.

    • cptshandy October 19, 2013 / 9:10 am

      Exactly. I like fine terrain, but I also like the ‘gamey’ aspect of the thing – I am no modeler per se.
      I think it also depends on where you personally draw the line regarding believability (or simulation, or whatever you want to call it): For some, it’s terrain, for others wrongly painted uniforms and for others rules that give no historical outcome.

  2. grantdyck October 19, 2013 / 9:31 am

    I own a piece of felt, and I have gamed on it.

    I also confess to wishing to own nicer terrain, but find myself confused when it comes time to try and make new terrain. I suck at it.

    • cptshandy October 19, 2013 / 9:48 am

      Yes, I oscillate between scratchbuilding and buying stuff. However, even though scratchbuilding can be a hassle and the results more often than not are rather mediocre, I try not to give in to the impulse to buy too often. Somehow, I like it when I know I built that watchtower myself, even though it might no look as perfect as a commercial one (it’s the same reason why I paint shields myself instead of using transfers, even though transfers would look much better. Call me crazy). And the Compendium contains some simple and effective ideas for terrain making!

  3. Bill Moreno October 19, 2013 / 10:51 am

    Terrain is my thing. However possessing this skill does not give me the right to denegrate others efforts. Felt can be made to look great. Bottom line is the hobby is about fun and friends.

  4. Alan October 19, 2013 / 11:38 am

    I use felt pieces on a felt cloth for a lot of my gaming. I put things on the felt to mark woods, rocky ground and so on, but the felt delineates the terrain, and the bits can be removed so that the figures – the point of the game – can move through it. Felt is quick, cheap and easy to store. I leave posh terrain to other people 🙂

    • cptshandy October 19, 2013 / 11:47 am

      Oh yeah, easy storage is also paramount for me! I wouldn’t even know where to put terrain tiles. There are some nice battlemats that can be rolled up though. However I never felt brave enough to get down and make one for myself, from what I have read it is a very messy process.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s